More Essential than Ever: The Fourth Amendment in the Twenty by Stephen J. Schulhofer

More Essential than Ever: The Fourth Amendment in the Twenty by Stephen J. Schulhofer

By Stephen J. Schulhofer

Whilst the states ratified the invoice of Rights within the eighteenth century, the Fourth modification appeared undemanding. It calls for that executive admire the proper of electorate to be "secure of their folks, homes, papers, and results, opposed to unreasonable searches and seizures." after all, "papers and effects" at the moment are electronic and therefore extra at risk of executive spying. however the largest possibility could be our personal weakening unravel to maintain our privacy.

In this powerful new quantity in Oxford's Inalienable Rights series, felony specialist Stephen J. Schulhofer argues that the Fourth modification continues to be, because the name says, extra crucial than ever. From data-mining to airport physique scans, drug trying out and competitive police patrolling at the streets, privateness is lower than attack as by no means before--and we're easily being used to it. however the development is threatening the pillars of democracy itself, Schulhofer continues. "Government surveillance won't fear the common citizen who reads best-selling books, practices a broadly authorized faith, and adheres to middle-of-the-road political views," he writes. yet surveillance weighs on minorities, dissenters, and unorthodox thinkers, "chilling their freedom to learn what they pick out, to claim what they suspect, and to go together with others who're like-minded." we all are affected, he provides. "When unrestricted seek and surveillance powers relax speech and faith, inhibit gossip and hose down creativity, they undermine politics and impoverish social lifestyles for everyone." Schulhofer bargains a wealthy account of the historical past and nuances of Fourth modification protections, as he examines such matters as highway stops, racial profiling, digital surveillance, info aggregation, and the calls for of nationwide safeguard. The Fourth modification, he reminds us, explicitly authorizes invasions of privacy--but it calls for justification and responsibility, necessities that reconcile public safeguard with liberty. Combining a close wisdom of particular instances with a deep grab of Constitutional legislations, More crucial than Ever offers a worldly and considerate standpoint in this vital debate.

Show description

Read Online or Download More Essential than Ever: The Fourth Amendment in the Twenty First Century PDF

Similar constitutional law books

The Migration of Constitutional Ideas

The migration of constitutional principles throughout jurisdictions is among the crucial gains of latest constitutional perform. The expanding use of comparative jurisprudence in examining constitutions is one instance of this. during this 2007 ebook, top figures within the learn of comparative constitutionalism and comparative constitutional politics from North the USA, Europe and Australia speak about the dynamic approaches wherein constitutional structures impression one another.

Interstate Economic Relations

A complete examine the industrial kinfolk between states, and the way they may be larger optimized. during this groundbreaking quantity, Joseph F. Zimmerman examines interstate monetary family. He explores the heritage of congressional and judicial floor ideas governing such family members, direct and oblique interstate exchange boundaries and technique of their removing, and interstate festival for tax sales, company enterprises, activities franchises, travelers, and gamblers.

Ordered Liberty: Rights, Responsibilities, and Virtues

Many have argued lately that the U. S. constitutional method exalts person rights over tasks, virtues, and the typical reliable. Answering the costs opposed to liberal theories of rights, James Fleming and Linda McClain boost and safeguard a civic liberalism that takes duties and virtues—as good as rights—seriously.

Privacy and the American Constitution: New Rights Through Interpretation of an Old Text

This ebook explains a paradox in American constitutional legislation: how a correct no longer mentioned throughout the ratification debates at Philadelphia and never pointed out within the textual content has turn into a center section of glossy freedom. relatively, privateness is a constitutional afterthought that has won strength via sleek interpretations of an outdated textual content.

Extra resources for More Essential than Ever: The Fourth Amendment in the Twenty First Century

Example text

13 Otis and the merchants lost their argument, at least in the short term. The Wilkes and Entick cases had not yet been decided in England, and without those rulings as a guide, a compliant Massachusetts court under Chief Justice Thomas Hutchinson ruled in * Otis evidently was referring to the execution of Charles I in 1649, following his conviction for high treason. Since oppressive searches and seizures had not figured prominently in the accusations against Charles, Otis apparently sought to suggest an analogy between the abuses of his own time and the tyrannical powers Charles had claimed—notably his attempts to rule and levy taxes without parliamentary consent.

This reality is not just a recent development. The historical evidence makes clear that the Framers themselves were not “originalists” in the narrow, literal sense. ” From the start, therefore, the Fourth Amendment represented much more than a code of specific law enforcement procedures. It was an expression of foundational values and a mandate to the courts to safeguard those values in the face of changing circumstances. Eighteenth-century practices are a starting point, but they cannot be the end of the matter.

Than the house of a citizen? . ”1 But just as respect for privacy is universal, so too is government’s appetite for information. Culture and historical experience shape each society’s conception of the government powers its citizens will tolerate and the specific safeguards they demand. Conflict between the king and his subjects over the right to privacy reached a fever pitch, both in the colonies and in Britain, in the mid-eighteenth century. Our core ideas about the limits of official authority were formed in the crucible of that controversy.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.66 of 5 – based on 8 votes
Comments are closed.